Normally I use 89. There was a discussion about using 91, so I thought I would try. After about 2 or three tanks I felt like the mix of 89 was gone. Coincidentally, on that tank I got the best milage I'd ever gotten, 92.5. But the next tank was 83.4. Since I ride basically the same road ever day that I ride and rarely go 50 mph I don't have any explanation for the difference. Maybe bad gas, I did get them at different stations. But for ten cents a gallon difference I'm going back to 89. There's not that bag a difference in mileage to offset the price.
Now, at last your question
Yes it could be bad fuel but if your using 89 octane and at a good station that has high usage, I would think probably not. If your getting gas from some little out of the way, mom and pop cause it's cheap, maybe.
Phil