Batman,
+1 to ALL of the above!
I have a 2012 Maroon C5 w/8525 miles on the clock, and haven't been more pleased with my decision to go for it. Also swapped to a braided steel line for the front brakes and consider them quite adequate.
As for all the negative comments the internet coughs up: Almost without exception the bad reviews and bitching about the bike are from people who do not understand the mindset and philosophy of owning a real motorcycle instead of an appliance. In other words...biased toward their particular flavor of bike.
Not fair to compare apples and oranges.
I bought mine because I've always loved the traditional styling, it was my intention all along to be its owner AND mechanic, and while I still have much to learn I'm pleased to pass on that not only is the newer RE affordable, it is exceptionally easy to maintain. I've been from Albuquerque NM to Aurora CO and back, encountering some really nasty weather and my C5 saw me through all of it without a glitch at an average speed of around 63mph.
That said, while the rear drum brakes are for the most part marginal compared to others, setup and maintenance is easy enough.
The stock Avons will serve you well. I still have just over 3/32" depth to my treads even with the 8525 miles.
You can expect some vibration which should gradually decrease as you rack up the miles. I now only feel a buzz in my feet when accelerating between 55 and 60mph. Each one is different, so the suggestion to test ride several is good advice indeed. The crank/piston is not counter-balanced and no two bikes will feel the same.
NP regarding truing and spokes.
Should come with a marginal tool kit, spare cables, and a can of touch-up paint.
Shifting gets smoother the more you use it.
Parts/Accessories are less expensive and readily available. OEM parts will soon not be available through our hosts due to the new distribution model for North America, but sourcing through the dealer or ebay should not present an issue.
Remember that much of the RE is still HAND MADE, so misalignment is common, but easily corrected. It's also part of the appeal.
And last, but not least...
THIS FORUM is the ONLY place you'll get truly good advice about any of the RE's! It's guys like Kevin (our host), ace.cafe, Bullet Whisperer, Gas House Gorilla, singhg5, and many others here that have set the benchmarks for honesty and technical expertise.
I love this place, and if the RE is for you, you will, too!