Chris,
There are plenty of good options for a C5.....Harley softail, Silman short bottle, megaphones.....etc. available on EBay, Hitchcocks, NFG. You will quickly figure out the pros and cons for each simply by scanning through 5 years worth of C5 muffler discussions! As the others have pointed out, a baffle in the header pipe isn't a good idea. Almost all 1 3/4" mufflers will need a little shim to fit tight on the header pipe. Thanks.
GSS